In a world filled with information, what’s the one thing we don’t know enough about? That’s right: donairs. Specifically, donairs in Red Deer. Idea Market is here to rectify that situation. First, a little background information…
History
According to Wikipedia, donairs are a variation of the Turkish doner kebab and were introduced in Halifax in 1973. At this point it’s worth noting that Carson was born not far from Halifax in 1973. Coincidence? We think not. Eventually, the recipe made its way to Alberta… around the same time that Carson did, in fact. Hmmm…
What is a Donair?
The traditional recipe for a Halifax-style donair is sliced spiced beef, tomatoes, onions and a sweet sauce, wrapped in a pita. This is different from gyros, which typically have lamb and a tzatziki sauce. In Alberta, most places also add lettuce to this recipe. We don’t know why.
Food Poisoning
Yes, it can happen. There was even an E. coli outbreak here in Alberta in the summer of 2008. Since then, new rules on cooking the meat have come into place, though it seems that not all of the places follow them. It should be noted that during our week-long study, Carson only got mildly sick once.
OK, let’s get down to the study. We bought a donair at each of the five primary donair joints in Red Deer over the course of the first week of July. We asked for the same thing at each place: a regular beef donair, with whatever they considered the “standard” toppings and sweet sauce. The making of each one was observed and the final product was weighed, studied and taste-tested. Here are the results:
Cleopatra’s Donair & Pizza (7110 – Gaetz Avenue / 403-341-5282)
price: $5.79
weight: 267g
grams/dollar: 46.1g
ingredients: beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet sauce
process: meat sliced with an electric shaver, then the whole thing put in a press.
review: not huge, but definitely delicious. A little out of the way from the rest, but worth it. Personal favourite.
King Donair & Shawrama (4942 – Ross Street / 403-356-1800)
price: $6.00
weight: 455g (1 pound!)
grams/dollar: 75.8g
ingredients: spicy beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet sauce (plus more sweet sauce)
process: meat sliced with an electric shaver, then just the meat cooked on a grill.
review: enormous, spicy and very messy. If you’ve got a big hunger and lots of napkins, this is the one.
Red City Donair & Pita (4949 – 49 Street / 403-343-1219)
price: $6.15
weight: 288g
grams/dollar: 46.8g
ingredients: beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet sauce
process: meat sliced with a knife, then the whole thing put in a press.
review: very similar to Cleopatra’s, which makes sense since it’s run by his wife. Also delicious.
Sam’s Donair (5020 Ross Street / 403-986-9500)
price: $5.50
weight: 408g
grams/dollar: 74.2g
ingredients: spicy beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet sauce
process: meat sliced with a knife, then just the meat cooked on a grill.
review: another big one. Sam used to own King Donair and this is pretty close to theirs, including the spiciness level. Not quite as messy.
Best Choice Donair (103, 4916 Ross Street / 403-754-2202)
price: $5.49
weight: 246g
grams/dollar: 44.8g
ingredients: spicy beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, homemade sweet sauce
process: meat sliced with a knife, then just the meat cooked in a frying pan.
review: the smallest of the bunch. The sauce is homemade, but either there wasn’t much there or it wasn’t as flavourful. Least favourite.
Lessons Learned
The first lesson is probably that donairs are only delicious 2-3 times in a week. Anything after that starts to get a little less appealing. The other big thing is to time your visit carefully. The ideal time to get the best meat is just after noon. That’s because sometimes they pre-cut slices of the meat in anticipation of the lunch rush – you don’t want that stuff. You want to be there just after that’s gone and you get nice, fresh meat off the spit.
Recommendations
You have two basic choices here: If you want a finely-crafted and lightly grilled donair, go to either Cleopatra’s or Red City. Note that our informal poll of other Red Deer donair lovers picked Red City as the number one choice. If you’re really feeling peckish and/or like your meat a little spicier, try Sam’s or King Donair. You won’t walk away hungry. Best Choice is pretty new to this, but we can’t recommend them at this time.
Please feel free to leave your own recommendations and reviews in the comments!







